Black eyeshadow is an acquired makeup taste that’s definitely not for everyone — and that’s OK! But for the beauty gurus out there who do love adding major drama onto their lids (ahem, us), we’re here to report that there are black eyeshadow products out there that aren’t as scary as they seem. Ahead, we rounded up five black eyeshadows that we challenge you to try.

Let's Stay in Touch

Get our top stories straight to your inbox!