The New Drugstore Eyeliner Pencil Everybody Needs in Their Lives

Everyone has a different relationship with their eyeliner. Some stick to the daily ritual of drawing on a cat eye while others prefer to just line their waterline. Whether you’re an eyeliner newbie or someone who has mastered the graphic eyeliner look, L'Oreal Paris Cosmetics Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyelinerdeserves a place in your collection.

The eyeliner pencil comes in six different shades: black, brown, cobalt blue, gray, beige and purple. Right now, we’re particularly obsessing over the cobalt blue for its rich pigmentation, as well as purple because Pantone (and L'Oreal Paris, clearly) knows how to beat winter blues with bold colors. The product goes on smoothly and has a creamy consistency that’s ideal for your waterline — it’s waterproof, smudge-resistant and can stand up to watery winter eyes (trust).

Here’s what some reviewers have to say on Amazon:

“The part I liked most about this eyeliner is how well it wears. I put it on early in the morning and went about my day-gym, work, dinner, and by evening when I rolled home, my eyeliner was still in place and looked great. My normal brand usually by this point has rubbed off and looks melted and has to be wiped clear and reapplied. This withstood the test of endurance and won! I love it,” explains Sajijoma.

“I was a little worried that this cobalt eyeliner would be too ‘showy’ for conservative me, but it turned out to be terrific. My eyes look blue or green depending on my clothing, and L'Oréal's offering made them the bluest they've ever looked.” Says Tamara Thorne.