Dark Pencils

Check out our selection of Dark Pencils. 

  • Define-A-Brow® Eyebrow Pencil

    "Love it!!...Love it...I loved Define-A-Brow pencil in the dark brown....I have been buying this for quite awhile, used to use a more expensive brand but I tried this and really liked it, but the latest one I bought broke each time I used it...not because of pressing too hard just broke EVERYTIME."

    Discover a long-lasting, waterproof eyebrow pencil with an eyebrow comb. Fill in eyebrows with our brow pencil formula for defined, natural eyebrows all day.

  • Brow Precise® Micro Pencil

    "Loved it....LOVE !...I think for someone else who has darker brows, this pencil would look great (in a darker color as well)....

    That said, let's talk about the product itself.I was quite excited to try this eyeliner because I love most of the maybelline products and after wearing it I was a bit disappointed.Firstly, I thought the color would be very clear to my eyebrows, but no, the color is perfect for me, but when I apply it I feel it costs a bit to be uniform and when I press it a bit to draw the shape of my eyebrows, the tip breaks and enough product is lost."

    Brow Precise Micro Pencil by Maybelline. Mechanical shaping eyebrow pencil with a fine tip and grooming brush to fill for full and natural looking eyebrows.

  • Auto Eyebrow Pencil

    "love it!...great buy...Definitely purchasing again just in a darker shade....Heck the one I'm currently using is still good even tho the pencil is giving out already which I need to buy My tip I use is the NYX brow pencil, & eye shadow and most important BLEND!"

    Create flawless arches with this eyebrow pencil, a blend of vegetable coconut and soy bean oil that guarantees a fluid application and sensational color. Use the built-in brush to blend color and style your eyebrows to perfection.

  • Micro Brow Pencil

    "I love it!...Love it!!!...Th ABH in dark brown is perfect for me....These brow pencils are amazing , I use the colour taupe and its perfect alone or alongside the brow pomade , I use blonde and they work amazing together , have repurchased numerous times, just love them"

    Build full beautiful brows with our ultra-thin Micro Brow Pencil. So precise it coats even the finest hairs with color for a natural-looking finish.

  • Slim Lip Pencil

    "My fave!!...I love it...I love the lip liner espresso and dark brown waiting to try new colors...I never would have picked this shade for myself but I'm so glad that Nyx did, I'm completely in love and ordered one the next time I shopped with them."

    Slim, trim, but never prim our lip pencils come in a variety of dashing shades - from auburn to orange and traffic-stopping red. The buttery long-wearing lip liner formula goes on easily and resists bleeding.

  • Jumbo Eye Pencil

    "A favorite...Love it...They apply very smooth too and the darker ones are very easy to blend!...Milk is like everyone's go to for sooo many things, highlighter, eyeliner, perfect base for shadows, I also use them to lighten or completely alter my lipsticks, just fill lips in with one and go over with lipstick and it's so nifty!"

    A radiant eyeliner that also doubles as an eyeshadow. Made with a blend of mineral oil and powder, our creamy Jumbo Eye Pencils glide on effortlessly—no pulling, tugging or fading—and come in a rainbow of vivid hues. Our most voluptuous pencil yet! Our Jumbo Eye Pencils can be sharpened with a sharpener that has an opening for a large pencil. Get your NYX Professional Makeup Sharpener here.

  • Slide On Pencil

    "My favorite...Very happy...The dark grey is also great....Amazing pigmentation, goes on so smooth, stays put all day (even in the waterline), and isn't a pain in the butt to remove at the end of the day."

    Don’t let the softness of this pencil fool you. This formula doesn't smear or smudge and delivers powerful robust colors. It’s like a liquid eye liner without the mess. Available in 18 sleek shades. Our Slide on Pencils can be sharpened with a sharpener that has an opening for a small pencil. Get your NYX Professional Makeup Sharpener here.

  • Wonder Pencil

    "Its so great!...A MUST HAVE!!...I purchased this in dark and I am in love....This pencil also great for under the eyebrows, around the outline of the brow or the outline of the lips to act as a barrier so tour lipstick will not bleed."

    Wonder Pencil…the essential pencil that fulfills all of your beauty desires. Conquer 3 critical make-up tasks with one product: CONCEAL flaws and blemishes with creamy precision; LINE your lips against lipstick bleeding and fading; and BRIGHTEN your eyes along the water line. Will wonders never cease? Not with the Wonder Pencil in your bag!

  • Unstoppable® Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil

    "Loving it...Best Eye Liner...It's dark and lovely....It also comes off better when you are trying to wash your face at the end of the day."

    Unstoppable Eyeliner Pencil, Eye Makeup by Maybelline. Smudge proof and waterproof eyeliner with a self sharpening point for beautiful eye makeup looks.

  • 3-in-1 Brow Pencil

    "I will say that I love the 3rd step which is the brow gel....Great Pencil and Powder...Amazing for my dark brows!...The crayon fills in sparse areas well without being clumpy."

    One unbeatable brow beautifier, three go-to goodies. Our versatile 3-in-1 Brow includes everything you need to build exquisite arches. A retractable pencil, Powder, and brow mascara, available in 10 pigmented shades. Achieve eyebrows that are as natural-looking or bold as you desire by applying these essentials alone or together. To combine ’em all, simply outline with the pencil and fill in with the Powder. Complete the look by setting your brows with a swipe of mascara.

  • Slim Eye Pencil

    "Great lip pencil!...Great colors...I'm dark skinned....It would be nice if they included a navy blue for a more subtle look, but overall I would recommend."

    Slim, trim, but never prim. Our Slim Eye Pencils come in a variety of entrancing shades—from seafoam green to black shimmer. The creamy long-wearing eye liner formula goes on easily and resists bleeding. Available in 31 stunning shades!

  • Precision Brow Pencil

    "I'm so glad I did!...Nice formula...The color deposit is dark, which is nice....it's only $10 but is literally the best eyebrow product I've used for drugstore."

    Let's get those brows in formation! Totally slay the sculpted look with our all-new Precision Brow Pencil. Available in eight natural-looking shades, this dual-ended pencil has a flat tip for outlining your arches and filling them in with detailed, hair-like strokes. The other side features a flexible spoolie-brush for seamless blending and getting your eyebrows into place.

  • Master Precise Skinny™ Gel Pencil

    "BEST EYELINER>>>EVER!...Great product!...I think the eyeliner has the potential to make a nice dark, thin line, if you can manage to put it on your eyelid....This eyeliner is perfect: the gel tends to stay in place, the control and definition is great."

    Master Precise Skinny Gel Eyeliner by Maybelline. Automatic waterproof gel pencil eyeliner provides sharp, mistake-proof application for up to 24 hours.

  • Eyestudio® Lasting Drama® Waterproof Gel Pencil

    "I love it...Love it!...1st two applications - beautiful, dark, instense, smooth....I agree with JaneC - love the way it looks, goes on and stays on - but HATE trying to sharpen it!"

    Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Pencil Eyeliner by Maybelline. Waterproof gel eyeliner with ultra smooth intensity that lasts for up to 16 hours.

  • Eyestudio® Brow Precise® Shaping Pencil

    "I would definitely recommend it!...I love how super easy it is to use and to fill in my sparse brow spots....More importantly, in comes in a "blonde" version, so I don't have to paint my brows black or dark brown when they're naturally all but invisible....Love the brush, works wonders."

    Eye Studio Brow Precise Shaping Pencil, Eyebrow Filler by Maybelline. A shaping pencil with natural wax and grooming brush to fill in brows for brow perfection.

  • Jumbo Lip Pencil

    "I love this....very Nice...What I can say is it looks amazing on my dark complexion....It goes on smooth and moisturizing but looks matte.it has a orange undertone that compliments my skin tone."

    It’s double or nothing with this lip liner and lipstick in one. Our Jumbo Lip Pencils infuse lips with alluring nourishing color and help you create a perfect pout. Line, define and color with one jumbo pencil. Plus, the mineral oil formula does not dry out your lips and it goes on smoothly. In 16 seductive shades, our Jumbo Lip Pencils can be sharpened with a sharpener that has an opening for a large pencil. Get your NYX Professional Makeup Sharpener here.

  • Slide On Lip Pencil

    "Love this...Smooth application...I bought 5 of these when they first came out; Nude Suede Shoes, Sugar Glass, Bedrose, Red Tape, & Dark Soul....I heard NYX sells a sharpener specifically made for this purpose but I personally use the wet 'n' wild dual pencil sharpener and it works just fine (: hope this helps!"

    Draw out your pout with a stroke of rich color. Our Slide On Lip Pencil is now available in 14 all-new shades—from bold blue-green to deep nude and pastel lilac. Like the much-loved eyeliner it’s named after, this waterproof lip pencil glides on super-smooth and delivers a highly pigmented Matte finish. Line your lips or fill ’em in for defined and enriched lip color using any of these 28 incredible shades. Our Slide on Lip Pencils can be sharpened with a sharpener that has an opening for a small pencil. Get your NYX Professional Makeup Sharpener here.

  • Eyebrow Powder Pencil

    "This is my favorite brow pencil...I love it...Most "blondes" look incredibly dark next to my "I've been living for months in a cave" type coloring....But this blonde gives the perfect definition without getting an unwanted Daenerys Targaryen brow."

    Close your eyes and picture the perfect brows. Are they defined, yet delicate? Create the brows of this daydream with the brand new Eyebrow Powder Pencil. Our unique pencil’s superfine texture provides a powdery-soft, matte finish. Put the finishing touches on your arches by using the included spoolie brush to smooth out the rich color.

  • Expert Wear® Twin Brow & Eye Wood Pencil

    "Excellent Staying Power!...It is waterproof,smear proof,pigmented and great....It goes on smoothly, provides natural-looking color (I use the dark brown), stays on all day and is even waterproof!...It is waterproof,smear proof,pigmented and great."

    ExpertWear Twin Brow & Eye Pencils, Eye Makeup by Maybelline. Dual-purpose waterproof eyebrow filler and precision eyeliner to shape eyebrows and define eyes.

  • Gotcha Covered Concealer Pencil

    "Works just as you would think....NYX Gotcha Covered is perfect!...Very nice for what it is....It is a super clean blend."

    Skin imperfections, beware! When it comes to covering up discoloration, our new Gotcha Covered Concealer Pencil does NOT mess around. Available in 20 blendable shades, this luxurious concealer is a master at spot concealing.



 

.