Mastering the cat eye is no easy feat — the hundreds of memes about the struggle to do it is proof. And while practice is the key to perfecting the skill that is winged liner, certain products make it a whole lot easier. Cue felt-tip eyeliners, a liquid eyeliner variety touted for its ease of use and flawless results. The magic is in the tip, which is essentially a marker soaked in black eyeliner that delivers pigment in an easy-to-control swipe. We’ve rounded up our favorite felt tip liners, perfect for creating the ultra-defined flick you know and love. Peep our picks, ahead: