I’ve always had a love-hate relationship with lip gloss. While I’m here for a high-glass, glossy finish, I’m not a fan of the fact that gloss doesn’t give my lips shape or definition. Plus if the consistency is anywhere near sticky, forget about it. Still, I’m always on the hunt for a product that will change my mind, so I recently tested out the new NYX Professional Makeup This Is Milky Gloss and let’s just say it surpassed my expectations. This Is Milky promises to give your lips a milky, velvety finish. It boasts 12 hours of hydration thanks to its vegan milk-infused formula, comes in eight shades and has a subtle-but-sweet scent. The shades I gravitated towards immediately were Cookies N Milk, a light beige-brown and Milk the Coco, a glossy high-shine brown. With my lips scrubbed and prepped, I was ready to give them a go.