The Best Mascara for Your Lash Type, According to Our Editors

January 28, 2021
By: | by L'Oréal
The Best Mascara for Your Lash Type

Although it’s easy to dismiss mascara as a one-size-fits-all beauty buy, it’s actually much more complex than that. Every formula is expertly created to meet specific lash needs — whether that be volume, length, or something in between. It makes choosing a mascara tricky, especially if you have lashes that require something otherworldly (short-lashed humans will know what I’m talking about). We’ve rounded up our favorite mascara formulas for special cases ahead — we promise they’re the best of the bunch.

Mascara for Straight Lashes

If your eyelashes are naturally straight, it’s likely you’ve struggled with finding a mascara that will hold a curl. We recommend using a lash curler before applying a waterproof formula, like the Maybelline Falsies The Lash Lift Waterproof Mascara, to help hold the curl all day long. This product has a curved brush designed to lift, volumize and lengthen even the straightest of lashes from root to tip.

Looking for a low-maintenance option or hate removing waterproof formulas? Try a lash lift instead, which curls lashes for six to eight weeks.

Mascara for Naturally Curled Lashes

Those with naturally curled lashes are what we like to call #blessed, so it’s likely you’re looking for a formula that offers volume and length. Luckily, lots of formulas are designed with those goals in mind. Our personal favorite? The Lancôme Lash Idôle Mascara, which offers lift, length and volume that still looks super natural. The formula is lightweight and won’t clump. If you want a more intense full-fringe look, just layer on a few more coats. 

Mascara for Fine Lashes

Anyone who has fine lashes knows the issue isn’t always making them look long, it’s that there aren’t many lashes to work with in the first place. That’s where volumizing and thickening mascaras come in. To get a fuller look, try the L’Oréal Paris Air Volume Mega Mascara. Not only does the lash-boosting formula give a multiplying effect, but the large bristle brush grips and coats every lash in a single stroke. This drugstore product is also dermatologist- and ophthalmologist- tested for sensitive eyes. 

Mascara for Short Lashes

For the stubby-lashed among us, don’t worry — it’s easy to cheat with a good lengthening mascara. We recommend opting for a formula that offers length and definition, which will make lashes look longer and fuller than they naturally are. Our go-to? The Maybelline New York Sky High Mascara, which offers a lengthened look from every angle. It has a flexible brush that lets you coat even the smallest, hard to reach lashes. 

Photo: Chaunte Vaughn

Read more