The Most Flattering Eyeliner Looks for Every Eye ShapeMay 26, 2021
Eyeliner is not your basic makeup staple. It’s the one product that can make or break your entire eye makeup look — transforming it from nice to naughty or subtle to dramatic. It can also shapeshift your eyes, giving the illusion that they're bigger, more lifted, wider or rounder. And just like skin tone and hair type, not all eye shapes are the same. Almond-shaped, monolid, hooded, round — there are different application techniques and products to best accentuate them. We consulted with makeup guru Emily Oliver to find out which eyeliners and looks are just right for you.
Almond eyes are often confused with round eyes. So how do you know if you’re rocking the almond shape? Check out your irises. If they’re slightly covered along the top and bottom edges by your lids, you have an almond shape.
While just about any eyeliner look will flatter your eyes, you can play up your almond shape by drawing a very thin line from the inner corners and intensifying the thickness as you near the outer corners. “Take a pigmented liquid liner and press into the lash line, following the natural shape,” says Oliver. Because almond eyes generally go upward at the ends, keep the liner close and clean with a tiny upward flick.” For a soft, smoky look, line your lower lash line as well and smudge both the top and bottom outer corners a bit. We recommend the Maybelline New York Eye Studio Master Precise Liquid Eyeliner for its ultra fine pen tip.
Recommended Makeup Looks: When trying eye makeup looks on almond eyes, the key is to enhance what you’ve got. Try a basic contouring technique that involves using a lighter shade on the lid and a darker, more intense shade on the outer crease to highlight your lovely almond shape.
News flash: Hooded eyes and monolids are not one in the same. In fact, a hooded eye shape is the exact opposite of a monolid, as a lid is present — it just droops or hangs over the natural crease of the eye, making it difficult for you to see it.
If you have hooded eyelids, thin liner looks are harder to see — which means a thick, bold wing will give your eye added definition. Oliver recommends a waterproof, smudge-resistant eyeliner, like the IT Cosmetics Superhero Liner, to ensure makeup doesn’t disappear into your lid or smear. “Push the liner into the lashline to keep the product from going too far on the lid,” she says.
Recommended Makeup Looks: Hooded eyes can sometimes give you a “sleepy” look. Counteract that with a wide-awake effect, courtesy of strategically placed highlighter. Apply a champagne or silvery beige shade into the inner corners of the eyes and the brow bone. Blend out the product so it looks natural.
Downturned eyes are pretty self-explanatory. They take on an almond-like shape, but dip or droop down at the outer corners.
When it comes to your downturned eye shape, the trick is in faking a lift. “Start the line much higher than you would think — try leaning your head back and making a line that goes 45 degrees from the middle of the eye outward toward the temple,” suggests Oliver. An upward flick of the liner at the outermost corner will instantly give your eyes an open and lifted appearance. Try a super-precise liquid liner that will keep your eyes lifted longer (we love the NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner).
Recommended Makeup Looks: Enlist the help of bright, contrasting colors to make your downturned eye look lifted. For example, this neon eyeliner look adds a pop of color and lift to your eyes.
What’s the opposite of a downturned, slightly drooping eye shape? A slightly lifted, upturned one, of course! The eyes draw upward at the outer corners, making them look slightly tilted.
While upturned eyes are similar to almond, your lower lid appears more prominent than your top lid. Oliver says the key is to enhance the natural symmetry and shape of the eyes. You can do so by lining the upper and lower lash line and applying a thicker line at the outer corner, then slightly diffusing with a smudger. Try the NYX Professional Makeup Epic Wear Liner Stick, which can be easily buffed out with a finger or smudge brush.
Recommended Makeup Looks: Complement your upturned eyes by adding some color and definition to the lower lash line. Have some fun by rocking a bright neon shade along the lower lash line and buffing it out.
If you have round eyes, they’re equally curved on the upper and lower lids, creating a naturally wide-eyed look. Plus you can see the whites of your eyes all the way around your iris, when looking straight ahead.
When it comes to the most flattering eyeliner look, the goal is to elongate the width of your eye shape to create balance. “I love to use a pencil liner and place it right next to the lashes,” says Oliver. Play up the outer corners with an elongated cat eye to create the illusion of length. For a more dramatic look, smudge a product like the Maybelline New York TattooStudio Smokey Gel Pencil Eyeliner along your upper and lower lash line. “This makes for a beautiful and easy look without adding more roundness to the eyes,” says Oliver
Recommended Makeup Looks: When working with round eyes, the key is to keep most of the party on top. In other words, use the most vivid and intense shades on the top lash line and outer corners. This curvy rainbow eyeliner look enhances the curves of your eyes and makes them look even wider.
No explanation needed here, right? While the overall goal is to expand your eye shape, going overboard on the product can actually work against you and make your eyes appear smaller.
There’s a simple solution to making your small eyes appear larger — line your waterline with either a nude or white liner (try the L'Oréal Paris Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil in Nude). Steer clear from using black on your waterline as it will make your eyes appear even smaller. “I tend to keep the product on the top lid only,” says Oliver. However, if you’re a stickler for all-over liner, go for it. Just line your bottom lash line and smudge the color a little in the outer corners to make your eyes appear wider.
Recommended Makeup Looks: Make your eyes pop with this barely-there, subtle nude makeup look.